In Spanish corporate law, directors’ remuneration is a significant issue for companies and individuals in these positions, sparking considerable controversy in recent years. Spanish legislation provides a legal framework that defines how directors’ compensation should be structured and the conditions that allow these amounts to qualify for deduction from Corporate Income Tax (CIT).
Legal Framework for Directors’ Compensation
The Spanish Companies Act (Ley de Sociedades de Capital, LSC) primarily regulates directors’ compensation in Spain. According to this law, directors can receive remuneration for their duties if the company’s bylaws explicitly establish it.
The LSC outlines the following principles:
- Compensation: The compensation may include fixed salaries, profit-sharing, or variable incentives.
- Proportionality: It should align reasonably with the company’s importance, financial status, and market standards.
- Sustainability: It must promote long-term profitability and sustainability.
Deductibility of Directors’ Compensation for Corporate Income Tax
From a tax perspective, companies can deduct directors’ compensation as an expense for Corporate Income Tax (CIT) purposes by fulfilling specific conditions.
CIT is levied on corporate profits, defined as revenue minus necessary business expenses. Directors’ compensation is deemed a crucial expense and is therefore deductible, reducing the taxable base.
Historically, tax authorities and case law required the following for deductibility:
- Bylaw Provision: The company’s bylaws must include the compensation structure and its maximum amount.
- Shareholders’ Agreement: The general meeting must approve the maximum annual compensation and its allocation among directors.
Jurisprudential Developments
Recent rulings from the Spanish Supreme Court in 2023 and 2024 have introduced significant flexibility in interpreting these requirements. Major changes include:
- Presumption of Deductibility: Compensation expenses are presumed deductible if duly justified.
- Relaxation of Formalities: Failure to meet some corporate formalities does not necessarily invalidate the deductibility of expenses proven to be business-related.
The Supreme Court highlighted the significance of accurately accounting for directors’ compensation. This requires precise expense records and evidence of services performed. It is crucial to monitor how tax inspections interpret and enforce this change in criteria in the future.
Conclusion
To mitigate risks of tax adjustments or penalties regarding the deductibility of directors’ compensation, companies should:
- Review Cases Thoroughly: Ensure compliance with the evolving legal framework.
- Monitor Tax Authorities’ Interpretation: Stay updated on how the Tax Authorities interpret and apply the Supreme Court’s new approach in practice.
Proper legal and tax advice is essential to align with these changes and safeguard the company’s interests.
If you need additional information about the deductibility of directors’ compensation in Spain,
