Spanish SMEs at the crossroads: where do we go from here?

Small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) are well known for playing a major role in all economies, being the key generators of employment and income.  As a result, SMEs are crucial for the economic recovery.

According to the information provided by the Spanish General Directorate of Industry and SMEs (Dirección General de Industria y de la Pequeña y Mediana Empresa) in its annual report SMEs 2012 Portrait [1], as of 1 January 2011, out of the 3,246,986 companies in Spain 3,243,185 (99,88%) were considered as SMEs [2].  Regardless of the different reasons that may lie behind such circumstances, these numbers evidence that SMEs dominate the business structure in Spain.

However, SMEs have been especially hard hit by the global crisis and hence are suffering a significant shortage of financing due to their problems of access to finance (A2F), which impedes their creation, growth and survival.  The current financial and economic crisis has impacted in a particularly severe manner the banking financing channel, which constitutes the major external source of finance for SMEs in Spain.

In Spain, the pre-crisis period was characterized by a favourable economic environment distinguished by, inter alia, the following factors:

  • The risk premiums applied to credit operations were very low not being under the risk assumed (due mainly to the high liquidity in the markets);
  • Low inflation and interest rates (also historically low), which encouraged investors to invest in assets of endless growth; and,
  • The rapid technological progress and innovation carried out by financial institutions enabled the entry of new products allowing the allocation of assets that, at the same time, provided liquidity to credit operations hardly liquid.

As of 2007, the development of the Spanish banking sector had been highly conditioned by the extent of the international crisis and the bursting of the housing bubble in Spain.  Likewise, the lack of confidence in the financial markets restricted Spanish banks’ access to financing in the international markets.

In September 2008, with the collapse of Lehman Brothers, the problem of liquidity became the most important differentiating factor of the crisis and as a result, wholesale markets were closed.  Since it was not possible to place any securitization or debt issuance of financial institutions, unforeseen risks of default of payment of financial institutions arose.  In a nutshell, market liquidity disappeared and financial entities turned off the credit tap.

The crisis in Spain has had (and has) singular features which particularly affect SMEs’ financing.  On the one hand, the default in payment (from individuals and entrepreneurs) has not only affected financial institutions’ profitability (using the need to allocate more funds) but also financial institutions’ solvency since such default has significantly reduced financial entities’ potential for self-financing through their funds.  On the other hand, the crisis has primarily affected saving banks (cajas de ahorros), which over the past had been granting more financing to SMEs (due to saving banks’ closer links with the traditional territory of action).

In light of the above, the main features of the actual crisis vis-à-vis SMEs in Spain, which are severely affecting SMEs’ cash flows, may be summarized as follows: (i) in a fewer offer of funds available, irrespectively of their origin (whether from banking or equity markets); and, (ii) in a toughening of their conditions (in terms of costs and instalments), which has made difficult not only their profitability but most crucial, their survival.  Consequently, the number of SMEs has been reduced dramatically due to the SME closures and the rapidly decreasing SMEs’ birthrate.

The problems of SMEs having external A2F are however not a new phenomenon nor unique to the Spanish SMEs.  In general terms (and according to the extensive economic literature that has been developed), the cause of these difficulties is linked to (among others) the existence of fixed costs regarding the provision of credit, which translates into a higher unit cost in smaller operations.  Likewise, the existence of major information asymmetries between suppliers and demanders of funds compared with those in operations performed by larger companies results in greater difficulty in assessing the risk of transactions for smaller companies who have reduced availability to assets that can be used as collateral in credit operations.

In addition, the economic and financial situation of SMEs is generally more vulnerable to cycle changes, being less diversified and less able to tackle adverse shocks.  The sharp drop in their results has reduced their ability to pay present and future liabilities, which, together with the increased difficulty of lenders to assess the risk of individual projects (in a context of high uncertainty), has increased the difficulties in accessing external finance.  Also, SMEs’ chances of getting internal funds have been limited due to their profit reduction.

The concern for these problems has led governments to deploy over the past years different cyclical measures of various kinds to mitigate the actual liquidity problem[3].  The most widely used policy measure has been the extension of public loans and loan guarantees.  In many cases, governments have also taken actions to ease liquidity problems, to reduce maximum payment periods in the public sector or to improve cash flow generation, reducing tax rates to smaller companies.

Among these measures and regarding mediation lines ICO[4] granted by the Spanish Official Credit Institute, the Spanish government has: (i) expanded the number of mediation lines; (ii) increased the amounts of current funding; (iii) introduced a mediation ICO line aimed at SMEs and self-employed in which ICO assumes 100% of the risk operation; and, (iv) has created a counselling service available for SMEs and self-employed who have been denied loans to improve access to finance to these groups.  Furthermore, the corporate tax rate for companies with a turnover of less than five million has been reduced.

Notwithstanding this, the findings of the Council of Chambers (CSC) survey on SMEs’ access to finance in the second quarter of 2012 are devastating: 30% of the operations requested by SMEs have been denied representing a decrease of 10% compared to the first quarter of this year.  Moreover, the number of SMEs that applied for funding from banks has been about half the average for SMEs who applied in 2010 and 2011.  In sum, far fewer SMEs have applied for funding and a lower percentage of SMEs that did apply achieved their goal.

Beyond these palliative sectoral policies, access to credit for SMEs will tend to improve as far as progress is made in the financial restructuring process and the uncertainties surrounding the national and international economic outlook and, most notably, those associated with the problems arising from the sovereign debt crisis in Europe clear up.

But even in a scenario of improved macroeconomic prospects, access to credit will be conditioned by the need to move forward in the process of deleveraging the private sector and other factors as the potential impact of the new Basel III regulation.

The measures now being adopted should include mechanisms that improve the prospects of Spanish SMEs expanding.  This necessarily involves reinforcing those channels and instruments that provide long-term financing and looking for solutions to the pressing problem of the lack of liquidity on which Spanish SMEs’ future will depend.

For additional information regarding SMEs in Spain,

[1] Report available here 

[2] The category of micro, small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) is made up of enterprises that employ fewer than 250 persons and which have an annual turnover not exceeding EUR 50 million, and/or an annual balance sheet total not exceeding EUR 43 million as defined in the EU recommendation 2003/361.

[3] See OECD’s report The Impact of the Global Crisis on SME and Entrepreneurship Financing and Policy Response which brings to the attention of governments recommendations to tackle the long-standing deficiencies in the SME financial environment, as well as to prepare SMEs and entrepreneurs for a phase of innovation-led growth. Available here.

[4] The Spanish Official Credit Institute (Instituto de Crédito Oficial or ICO) is developing a set of actions aimed at facilitating economic and business activity. Among its objectives is to facilitate access to finance for the start or consolidation of SMEs. Likewise, in Spain, the Compañía Española de Refinanciación (CERSA) provides the second tier of the national second-level guarantee fund to loans granted by mutual guarantee companies to SMEs that require additional guarantees to get access to finance.

Please note that this article is not intended to provide legal advice.

Related Articles